Celebrating National Peanut Butter Lover’s Day with Cakes Reanimated in Cape Girardeau

CAPE GIRARDEAU, MO – In honor of National Peanut Butter Lover’s Day, Cakes Reanimated, a beloved local bakery known for its scratch-made confections, is showcasing its peanut butter-themed treats. Owned by Becky Brown, the bakery at 720 Themus offers a variety of baked goods that incorporate this nutty ingredient in delightful ways.

Becky Brown, the heart and talent behind Cakes Reanimated’s delicious creations, shares her passion for peanut butter in an array of baked goods. “Oh, as much as I possibly can,” Brown said regarding how she uses peanut butter in her recipes. Patrons can indulge in mini peanut butter cookies, chocolate peanut butter cupcakes with salted caramel, peanut butter Rice Krispy bonbons, and a unique, taco-styled 6-inch peanut butter cookie with peanut butter buttercream.
“I feel like whenever you add the nuttiness of the peanut butter, along with some salt in there, it’s just a really nice balance to everything.”
Becky Brown – Cakes Reanimated

When asked about her favorite peanut butter desserts to make, Brown doesn’t hesitate. “I’ve always been a sucker for peanut butter cookies,” she expressed. Highlighting the importance of balance in flavor, she added, “I feel like whenever you add the nuttiness of the peanut butter, along with some salt in there, it’s just a really nice balance to everything.”
Brown also offered advice for home bakers eager to embrace peanut butter in their creations, emphasizing the use of real butter and salt to achieve a balance between sweetness and rich flavor. “Definitely use salt and use real butter,” she recommended for those wanting to explore peanut butter baking.
For customers looking for ingredient suggestions, Brown declared her preference for creamy peanut butter, calling it the tastiest and easiest to work with in the bakery.
Brown suggests the best way to celebrate National Peanut Butter Lover’s Day is to visit a favorite bakery or relish a classic peanut butter and jelly sandwich. For those who prefer a savory twist, she recommends peanut butter chicken from Rice Noodle Cai.

“I’ve always been a sucker for peanut butter cookies,”
Becky Brown – Cakes Reanimated

Cakes Reanimated invites the peanut butter enthusiasts and the curious alike to step into their store from 11 AM to 5 PM, Wednesday through Saturday, to explore their peanut butter-infused assortment – a true testament to the universally adored spread.
For more information about the bakery and its offerings, readers can visit Cakes Reanimated at their location in Cape Girardeau or follow them on social media for updates on their latest creations.
Visit Cakes Reanimated: 720 Themis Street, Cape Girardeau, MO, United States, Missouri
Bon Bon’s of Cape Girardeau Unveils a Peanut Butter Extravaganza

CAPE GIRARDEAU, MO At the heart of the city’s dessert scene downtown, Bon Bon’s of Cape Girardeau, a local bakery known for its creative confections, has become a haven for peanut butter enthusiasts. Stephanie Gardiner, the bakery’s founder, revealed to our correspondent that her own craving for peanut butter has inspired an array of sweet treats featuring the versatile ingredient.

In a recent discussion, Gardiner outlined the wide range of offerings that include peanut butter. “We use peanut butter in our Smash cookies, in our grilled PBJs. We have peanut butter brownies, peanut butter blondies. We make peanut butter cake. We do a lot of chocolate peanut butter melts,” she said, highlighting the diverse applications of peanut butter in Bon Bon’s menu.
“Smooth peanut butter all the way,”
Stephanie Gardiner – Bon Bon’s of Cape Girardeau
When asked about the most enjoyable creations to make, Gardiner admitted that the new line-up arose out of personal desire. “Those we just kind of started doing, and it was just because I had a craving for peanut butter, so we use those. Those are fun,” she explained.

The bakery’s commitment to catering to all tastes is evident, but Gardiner’s preference is clear when it comes to the peanut butter texture debate. “Smooth peanut butter all the way,” she declared.

Bon Bon’s, with its innovative approach to traditional ingredients, continues to delight patrons and confirms that whether crunchy or smooth, there’s no shortage of ways to enjoy the beloved spread. As Gardiner’s spontaneous cravings translate into delicious creations, customers can anticipate a continually evolving menu that keeps their palates guessing.
Visit Bon Bon’s of Cape Girardeau: 125 N. Water St., Cape Girardeau, MO, United States, Missouri
Bon Bon’s of Cape Girardeau Website
Bon Bon’s of Cape Girardeau Facebook
My Daddy’s Cheesecake Celebrates National Peanut Butter Lovers Day with Unique Desserts

CAPE GIRARDEAU, MO – In commemoration of National Peanut Butter Lovers Day, My Daddy’s Cheesecake has been attracting peanut butter enthusiasts with a delectable variety of peanut butter-infused desserts. According to Zack Stanfield, a staff member at the bakery, their perennial offerings like peanut butter cookies and the beloved chocolate peanut butter cheesecake are complemented by a rotating selection of treats such as peanut butter Texas sheet cake and peanut butter candy bars.

“I don’t like peanuts, but I like peanut butter,”
Zack Stanfield – My Daddy’s Cheesecake

Stanfield, enthusiastically endorses the Reese’s peanut butter cookie as his personal favorite. “It’s loaded and kind of probably the best one, I think,” he declared, indicating a preference which many regulars share. Recognized for its diverse range of baked goods, the bakery ensures there’s always something new for patrons to enjoy.
Discussing the use of peanut butter, Stanfield revealed he favors smooth peanut butter, appreciating its texture and versatility without the crunch of nuts. “I don’t like peanuts, but I like peanut butter,” he said, explaining how it can enhance various desserts, such as cheesecake, by offering a rich flavor that satisfies both peanut butter and cheesecake lovers alike.

In the world of baking, according to Stanfield, peanut butter has significantly influenced the array of recipes and innovations. Bakers have the freedom to experiment with the ingredient, leading to creations such as peanut butter and jelly bars or peanut butter and jelly cheesecake – a limited-time treat that showcases the bakery’s inventive approach.

As National Peanut Butter Lovers Day is celebrated, Stanfield encourages visitors to stop by and explore the wide selection at My Daddy’s Cheesecake, suggesting that customers may find a new favorite among their updated and traditional offerings. “Come in, check it out, and see which is going to be your favorite,” he invites.


My Daddy’s Cheesecake continues to serve up joy to peanut butter aficionados and dessert lovers alike, ensuring that the appreciation for this beloved spread is well acknowledged and tastefully honored.
Visit My Daddy’s Cheesecake: 265 S Broadview St, Cape Girardeau, MO, United States, Missouri
My Daddy’s Cheesecake Facebook
Like this article? Contact us about writing an article for your establishment.
Photography by Jonathan Fritzler- Heartland Eats and Treats